Caste

Eklavya. I hope we’re not that deep into Kaliyuga that many don’t even know who he is. Still, just for the sake of it, he is a character in the Mahabharata. A prince of the Nishadas, a forest-dwelling tribal community, came in conflict with both the Pandavas and Kauravas due to his unbelievable skill in archery. He was self-taught, simply practicing in front of a statue of the Guru Dronacharya, who, himself, refused to teach him because people from his community had no business learning war or combat skills, according to the rules of the time. Still, he did, and it was an issue because he was even better than Arjuna, Dronacharya’s disciple whom he had promised to make the world’s greatest archer. Since it wasn’t possible because of Eklavya, Dronacharya had an idea. He suddenly accepted being Eklavya’s guru and asked him for Guru Dakshina (anything he could ask him as a fee for his teachings) and for it, he asked for Eklavya’s right thumb, which he readily gave him and after which, he was no longer as perfect at archery as he was before.

The brilliance of Mahabharata is that it is more relatable to modern life than we presume it to be, based on it being an old text from the ancient times. It is known to highlight the problems, hypocrisies, injustice, and darkness that reside in all humans, whether they are ‘heroes’ or ‘villains. The point of this story is debatable. Some will consider that it is about upholding Dharma (Guru Dronacharya kept his word to Arjuna, Eklavya was breaking the rules and so balance was set) and others will call it a story of great injustice with Eklavya as the victim (of course because when he was rejected for being a Nishada, he made himself better than a Kshatriya, only to lose it to trickery from a so-called “great saint”) This story is also considered by some as a classic example of the caste system in India.

Hinduism has classified people into 4 castes that define what jobs they can do, what duties and what privileges they have. These castes are the Brahmins (priests, teachers), Kshatriyas (rulers, warriors), Vaishyas (landowners, merchants) and Sudras (servants), and now also a 5th group, the group of the untouchables, called Dalits. This was originally called the Varna system. One of Hinduism’s holy books, the Srimad Bhagavatam clearly states that varnas must base on skills, qualities and activities. However, not many care for these details.

Being a part of Hindu society in ancient times, this system was a method to give roles suitable to a person so that they may contribute to the best of their abilities to make a properly functioning society. It was needed in those times. But as time progressed, corrupt orthodox beliefs seeped in the minds of people through various factors such as lack of proper education, caste supremacy or even because of foreign powers such as the British who divided the people on basis of such factors to rule over them as the “one true unifying power”. Thus, it became a tradition and people stopped seeing this as a logical way of the old times to determine people’s abilities, but instead as a hierarchal class system. Religion, followed properly, has never asked people to stop thinking logically but that is what they do in its name.

The problem is mainly of the lower castes suffering at the hands of upper castes, who deem them “spiritual pollutants”. Many Adivasis (indigenous people) fight to save their ancestral land from being taken away and Dalits are forced into disgusting and demeaning jobs such as manual scavenging, garbage collectors, road sweepers etc. Some Dalits even do jobs of selling hides of dead cows, a controversial and dangerous job as cows are holy animals in Hinduism (being given the title of “Mata” or mother). So, due to this, they face hostility from ‘cow vigilantes’ or other militant Hindu groups who subject them in tortures ad public humiliations as a result.

Almost 3 years after India gained independence from the British on January 26, 1950, the Indian Constitution went into effect. Many people worked to establish the foundation of this secular, democratic republic and endeavoured to put all the written words into practice, including the highly regarded Dr. B. R. Ambedkar. The constitution includes a provision that aims to reduce injustices brought on by the caste (also known as jati) system. For instance, better the status of dalit (outcaste) people, who at the period of Hindu practice were frequently discriminated against, ignored, and degraded.

But writing something and following it are two different things. Even after 73 years, India faces this problem. A dalit man was murdered because he ate in front of folks from higher castes. For swimming, three Dalit boys were stripped and thrashed. Many people experience discrimination daily. For example, students who are constantly bullied later find it difficult to find employment. Because of their origin, people are intimidated, humiliated, and live in terror. Discrimination of this kind makes it difficult to earn a living, buy food daily, or live a good life without financial stress, which serves as fertile ground for even more heinous deeds. The most vulnerable people would occasionally resort to selling their daughters as sex slaves (devadasi) or forcing their children into illegitimate marriages to live.

As a Brahmin myself, I wonder sometimes what the point of any of these is. A person’s birth doesn’t necessarily determine what they will do in the future. In the Gurukuls, a Kings son had to sit and learn with a poor man’s son. Both being equal in the eyes of the Guru. No one who has come to study should be discriminated against, no matter where they come from. It is everyone’s right to be educated and have a chance to prove themselves. Just because a child is born a Dalit, doesn’t mean they aren’t capable of learning. Perhaps he/she becomes so because everyone else is against it.

Coming back to the Eklavya story, it is often said that it is Karma at play with him. Because of a past life’s mistake, he was forced to take birth in a Nishada community despite having the skills of a Kshatriya. Perhaps all those billions of Dalits and Outcastes have had bad Karma, who knows? But what I know is that the uppercastes also have no business in depriving them of their basic rights or even talking the law in their own hands most of the time.

Let me be clear, problems like these have existed all around the world. Not just India. It’s a natural thing in humans, to try to be superior than others. We are ‘social animals’ and for us, its more than just ‘survival of the fittest’. So, these problems are bound to happen. But the times as they say, “are a changin”. Many lower castes are also rising. There are Dalit millionares and CEOs that have climbed the steps of high society like Rajesh Saraiya, Nattha Ram, Milind Kamble, etc (all CEOs of their own companies). Even our current President Shree Draupadi Murmu and previous president Shree Ram Nath Kovind are respectively an Adivasi and a Dalit. So, there is no doubt that there are opportunities being given to the lower castes but it is still not on that level as it should it. So, it is only advisable to spread awareness and educate people on such matters and to take strict actions against those who break the rules. Only this way can we solve this issue.

Caste, as Krishna rightly points out in Verse 13 of Chapter 4 of the Bhagavad Gita, is not based on birth: “The fourfold caste has been created by Me according to the differentiation of Guna and Karma…” Guna means one’s qualities and karma means the “kind” of work one does. So, even God himself made it clear, it’s the people who have to do it now.